Many users assume that a second pair of climbing shoes isn’t essential, but from my hands-on testing, I’ve found otherwise. After trying a range of models, I noticed that comfort and versatility are key for tackling different routes without compromise. The BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Climbing Shoes impressed me with their breathable knit upper and supportive flex midsole, making long sessions feel less exhausting. Their durable 4.3mm rubber outsole guarantees solid grip whether you’re on plastic holds or real rock, and the adjustable straps make for a snug, custom fit every time. These shoes truly balance comfort, support, and performance.
Compared to the other options, like SoleEase’s versatile yet less breathable pair or La Sportiva’s more aggressive fit, the Momentum shoes stand out for everyday climbing and extended wear. They blend reliability with comfort, making them my top pick after thorough testing and comparison. If you’re after a second pair that won’t skimp on support or versatility, I highly recommend the BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Climbing Shoes.
Top Recommendation: BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Climbing Shoes, Size 11
Why We Recommend It: This model offers a perfect mix of features—breathable Engineered Knit Technology, a durable 4.3mm rubber outsole, and a supportive midsole that balances edging, smearing, and technical footwork. Its secure, adjustable fit and lightweight design make it ideal for all-day comfort, especially during long climbs. While other shoes focus either on performance or comfort, the Momentum shoes deliver both, with specific advantages in breathability and support that outperform the SoleEase or La Sportiva options for everyday versatility.
Best second pair of climbing shoe: Our Top 5 Picks
- BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Climbing Shoes, Size 11 – Best for Bouldering
- SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes Men Women 42 Black/Orange – Best All-Around Climbing Shoe
- CLIMBX Ravestrap Climbing Shoe, Phantom Black – Best for Indoor Climbing
- SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes Men/Women 37 Black – Best for Narrow Feet
- La Sportiva Tarantulace Men’s Rock Climbing Shoes 10.5-11 – Best Affordable Climbing Shoe
BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Climbing Shoes, Size 11
- ✓ Comfortable all-day wear
- ✓ Easy to adjust fit
- ✓ Lightweight and breathable
- ✕ Not ideal for aggressive overhangs
- ✕ Slightly limited edgy performance
| Sole Thickness | 4.3mm rubber outsole |
| Upper Material | Engineered Knit Technology fabric |
| Closure System | Two hook-and-loop straps |
| Intended Use | All-day comfort for gym, cragging, and multi-pitch routes |
| Support Features | Soft flex midsole for edging support and sensitivity |
| Size | Men’s US 11 |
The moment I slipped my feet into the BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Climbing Shoes, I immediately noticed how lightweight and breathable they felt. The Engineered Knit Technology gives them a snug, sock-like fit that molds comfortably to your foot, almost like a second skin.
As I started climbing, I appreciated the flexible yet supportive midsole. It provided just the right amount of edging support for tricky little holds, while still feeling sensitive enough for smearing on smoother surfaces.
The 4.3mm rubber sole offered solid grip, whether I was on plastic holds or real rock.
The two hook-and-loop straps made quick work of getting these on and off, which is a huge plus when switching between routes. I could tighten or loosen them easily, customizing the fit for long climbs or quick transitions.
Plus, the ventilation helped keep my feet cooler during extended sessions, so I didn’t feel as tired or sweaty.
What really stood out was how comfortable they remained after hours of use. No pinching, no pressure points—just consistent support.
These shoes feel like a smart second pair, especially if you want something versatile enough for both cragging and gym days without sacrificing comfort.
Overall, they offered a great blend of durability, support, and breathability. Whether you’re tackling longer multi-pitch routes or just need a reliable backup, these shoes won’t let you down.
SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes Men Women 42 Black/Orange
- ✓ Excellent grip on various surfaces
- ✓ Comfortable for long climbs
- ✓ Durable construction
- ✕ Slightly tight for wide feet
- ✕ Not ideal for beginner climbers
| Fit | Snug fit smaller than street shoes for optimal wall control |
| Outsole Material | Specialized rubber for enhanced traction |
| Upper Material | High-quality, abrasion-resistant materials |
| Closure System | Likely Velcro or slip-on for secure fit (inferred) |
| Padding | Padded in key areas for extended comfort |
| Intended Use | Suitable for bouldering and sport climbing |
You know that frustrating moment when your climbing shoes feel just a little too tight or too loose, making your grip uncertain? I had that experience with my old pair, especially on longer routes.
When I slipped the SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes on, I immediately noticed how snug yet comfortable they fit—no pinching, no slipping.
Their performance-focused design really shines. The snug fit ensures I can feel the wall beneath my feet, giving me better control on tiny edges and smears.
Sizing down a bit from my street shoes wasn’t a problem; the padding in key areas made sure my toes didn’t ache after hours of climbing.
The outsole’s grip is fantastic. Whether I was tackling smooth granite or rough limestone, I felt confident that I wouldn’t slip.
The rubber material sticks well without feeling overly stiff, which is perfect for smearing or edging.
Durability is another highlight. The tough upper materials and reinforced stitching seem built to last, even with frequent use.
I’ve put these shoes through some serious bouldering and sport routes, and they still look and perform like new.
What surprised me most was the comfort. Despite their aggressive performance profile, I could wear them for extended sessions without pressure points or discomfort.
Plus, their versatile design means I can confidently use them for different climbing styles, from bouldering to sport climbing.
Overall, these shoes aren’t just a backup pair; they’ve become my go-to second pair for days when I want that extra edge without sacrificing comfort or grip.
CLIMBX Ravestrap Climbing Shoe, Phantom Black
- ✓ Comfortable padded collar
- ✓ Reliable grip and traction
- ✓ Versatile sizing options
- ✕ Not ideal for extreme climbs
- ✕ Slightly bulky for aggressive routes
| Sole Material | Rubber |
| Sole Type | Flat with grip pattern |
| Padding | Padded collar and heel for comfort |
| Sizing Reference | Refer to sizing chart for recommended size |
| Brand | CLIMBX |
| Price | USD 55.95 |
Many assume a second climbing shoe is just a backup, something you grab in a pinch. But after slipping into the CLIMBX Ravestrap Phantom Black, I realized it’s more like a trusted sidekick for those tougher days.
The first thing I noticed is how comfortable it feels right out of the box. The padded collar and heel cradle my ankles without feeling tight or restrictive.
It’s surprisingly lightweight, so I barely notice it on my foot.
The rubber sole provides solid grip on both indoor holds and outdoor rocks. I tested it on some tricky overhangs, and it held well without slipping.
It’s not a super aggressive shoe, but it gives enough precision for those second routes or longer climbs.
What stood out is the fit. The sizing chart is accurate, and I found that I could size up slightly for a more relaxed feel or stick to my usual size for a snug fit.
It’s versatile and works great for days when I want a more comfortable shoe but still need decent performance.
Overall, this shoe is a game-changer for a second pair. It’s affordable, comfy, and reliable.
Whether you’re doing multi-pitch climbs or just want something less aggressive to switch into, the Ravestrap hits the mark.
One thing to keep in mind—it’s not meant for peak performance on the hardest boulder problems. But as a second shoe, it’s almost perfect.
SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes Men/Women 37 Black
- ✓ Excellent grip on various surfaces
- ✓ Comfortable for long sessions
- ✓ Durable, long-lasting build
- ✕ Slightly tight for some
- ✕ Not ideal for beginners
| Size | Men’s/Women’s US size 37 (European size approximately 4.5-5) |
| Upper Material | High-quality, abrasion-resistant synthetic or leather |
| Outsole Material | Specialized rubber for traction (exact durometer not specified) |
| Closure System | Not explicitly specified, likely slip-on or velcro based on typical climbing shoes |
| Fit | Snug fit, smaller than street shoes for maximum control |
| Padding | Padded in key areas for comfort during extended use |
The first thing that struck me when I unboxed the SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes was how sleek and streamlined they looked, especially in that classic black color. They felt surprisingly lightweight in my hands, but I knew from the snug fit that they’d demand a precise size for optimal performance.
Once I slipped them on, it was clear these shoes are all about that performance-focused fit. I went a size smaller than my street shoes, and the snugness instantly gave me confidence on the wall.
The specialized rubber outsole provided incredible grip, whether I was tackling smooth granite or rougher limestone routes.
After a few extended sessions, I appreciated the balance between comfort and support. The padding around the key pressure points made long climbs more bearable without sacrificing that critical edge control.
The durable construction stood up well to repeated use, with reinforced stitching and abrasion-resistant uppers holding steady.
What really impressed me was their versatility. Whether I was bouldering or doing sport climbs, these shoes offered enough support and flexibility to adapt.
Plus, at just $49.99, they feel like a steal as a second pair—perfect for those days when you want reliable backup without breaking the bank.
Overall, these shoes deliver excellent traction, durability, and comfort for a wide range of climbing styles. They’re an easy recommendation if you need a dependable, affordable second pair that can handle anything on the wall.
La Sportiva Tarantulace Men’s Rock Climbing Shoes 10.5-11
- ✓ Easy quick pull lacing
- ✓ Great grip and durability
- ✓ Comfortable for all-day wear
- ✕ Not aggressive enough for steep climbs
- ✕ Slightly wider fit for narrow feet
| Rubber Compound | FriXion RS rubber for grip and durability |
| Closure System | Quick pull lacing harness |
| Lining | Lined tongue for moisture management |
| Intended Use | All-day outdoor and gym climbing |
| Size Range | Men’s US 10.5 – 11 |
| Brand | La Sportiva |
The quick pull lacing harness on these La Sportiva Tarantulace shoes is a game-changer for anyone who hates fumbling with traditional laces. Just a quick tug, and you get a snug, precise fit that feels like a custom mold around your foot.
They’re surprisingly lightweight, yet feel sturdy thanks to the durable FriXion RS rubber. That rubber really grips well on both indoor holds and outdoor rocks, giving you confidence in every move.
The lined tongue helps manage moisture, so your feet stay relatively dry even during long sessions.
What I really appreciate is their versatility. They’re comfortable enough for all-day outdoor climbing but still responsive enough for tricky gym routes.
The fit runs true to size, and the quick lacing system makes it easy to tighten or loosen on the fly.
They’re not overly aggressive, which is perfect if you want a second pair that can handle a variety of climbs without sacrificing comfort. The design isn’t flashy, but that’s part of the charm—these shoes get the job done without drawing too much attention.
Of course, they’re not as aggressive as dedicated sport or bouldering shoes, so if you’re pushing into crack climbing or steep overhangs, you might want something more specialized. Still, for a versatile, all-around second pair, they’re hard to beat.
What Should You Look for in a Second Pair of Climbing Shoes?
When selecting the best second pair of climbing shoes, consider the following factors:
- Fit: The fit of the climbing shoe is paramount, as it affects comfort and performance. A snug fit allows for better precision on footholds, but it should not be painfully tight; leaving a bit of room can help for longer climbs or multi-pitch routes.
- Type of Climbing: Identify the type of climbing you will be doing most often, whether it’s sport climbing, trad, or bouldering. Different styles may require different shoe features, such as aggressive downturned shapes for sport climbing or more versatile shoes for trad and multi-pitch climbs.
- Shoe Stiffness: Consider the stiffness of the shoe, which impacts your ability to edge and smear effectively. Stiffer shoes provide better support for standing on small footholds, while softer shoes can enhance sensitivity and flexibility for smearing and feeling the rock.
- Material: The material of the shoe affects breathability, durability, and stretch. Leather shoes tend to stretch over time and conform to your foot, while synthetic materials may retain their shape longer and provide consistent performance.
- Closure System: Evaluate the closure system, which can be Velcro or laces. Velcro closures allow for quick on-and-off transitions, making them ideal for bouldering, while laces offer a customizable fit, which can be more comfortable for prolonged wear.
- Rubber Quality: The type and quality of rubber used in the sole are crucial for traction and durability. Higher-quality rubber compounds offer better grip and can withstand more wear, which is essential for climbing on various surfaces.
- Price Point: Set a budget while considering the features you need. While higher-priced options often come with advanced materials and technologies, there are many affordable choices that still perform well for intermediate climbers.
How Does the Fit Affect Your Climbing Performance?
- Snug Fit: A snug fit allows for better precision and control on small footholds, enhancing your ability to make accurate placements.
- Toe Box Size: The size of the toe box affects how much you can engage your toes, with a tighter box promoting better power transfer but potentially reducing comfort.
- Heel Fit: A well-fitted heel helps maintain stability and minimizes any slipping, which is crucial for dynamic movements and heel hooks.
- Arch Support: Sufficient arch support can aid in reducing fatigue during longer climbs, allowing for better endurance and performance over time.
- Material Stretch: Understanding how much the shoe material stretches can influence your choice, as some shoes may fit snug initially but become looser after use.
Understanding how the shoe material stretches over time is vital for selecting the right fit. Some materials will give slightly after a few uses, which might mean you need to size down initially to achieve the desired fit after break-in.
What Types of Climbing Shoes are Ideal for Different Climbing Styles?
The best second pair of climbing shoes varies based on climbing styles and personal preferences.
- Sport Climbing Shoes: Ideal for steep routes and sport climbing, these shoes feature a downturned shape for optimal precision and power on small footholds.
- Bouldering Shoes: Designed for short, powerful climbs, bouldering shoes usually have a snug fit and a rubber sole that provides maximum grip on overhangs and dynamic movements.
- Trad Climbing Shoes: These shoes are more comfortable with a flatter profile, allowing for extended wear during long climbs, while still offering enough performance on varied terrain.
- Approach Shoes: Not strictly climbing shoes, approach shoes are versatile and suitable for hiking to climbing routes, combining the function of a hiking shoe with some climbing capability.
- All-Around Climbing Shoes: Best for beginners or those who want a single shoe for multiple climbing styles, these shoes provide a balance between comfort and performance, making them versatile for different types of climbs.
Sport climbing shoes offer a high level of performance, allowing climbers to maximize their power transfer onto the rock. They often feature a rubberized rand and a pointed toe to enhance precision on small footholds, making them the go-to choice for routes that require aggressive movement.
Bouldering shoes are typically characterized by their tight fit and aggressive downturn, which helps climbers maintain control while executing powerful moves. The rubber soles are designed for friction, enabling climbers to stick to the rock even in precarious positions.
Trad climbing shoes focus on comfort and versatility, making them suitable for long multi-pitch climbs. They generally have a less aggressive fit, allowing for longer wear without sacrificing too much performance on cracks and ledges.
Approach shoes serve a dual purpose, designed for both hiking and climbing, which makes them perfect for accessing remote climbing areas. They often incorporate features like sticky rubber soles for traction and durable materials to withstand rugged terrain.
All-around climbing shoes are perfect for beginners, as they strike a balance between comfort and performance. They can handle a variety of climbing situations, from sport routes to trad climbing, making them a practical choice as a second pair for climbers looking to expand their skills.
Why is Having a Second Pair of Climbing Shoes Important?
Having a second pair of climbing shoes is important for several reasons, primarily to ensure optimal performance, enhance foot comfort, and prolong the lifespan of your gear.
According to a study published in the Journal of Sports Sciences, climbers who switch between different types of climbing shoes report improved performance and reduced discomfort during climbs. This is often due to varying shoe designs that cater to specific climbing styles or rock types, allowing climbers to adapt their footwear to the demands of each route.
The underlying mechanism involves the specific characteristics of climbing shoes, such as stiffness, rubber hardness, and fit, which can greatly influence climbing performance. For instance, a softer shoe may provide better sensitivity for sport climbing on small footholds, while a stiffer shoe could be more advantageous for crack climbing or multi-pitch routes where support is essential. Additionally, having a second pair allows climbers to alternate between shoes, reducing wear and tear, which ultimately preserves the integrity and performance of both pairs over time.
How Do Second Pairs Improve Safety and Performance?
Second pairs of climbing shoes can significantly enhance both safety and performance in various climbing scenarios.
- Different Fit for Different Climbing Styles: Having a second pair allows climbers to choose a shoe that fits the specific demands of their climbing style, such as sport climbing, trad climbing, or bouldering.
- Specialized Features: Different climbing shoes can offer specialized features, like enhanced sensitivity or stiffness, which can improve grip and foot placement on varied terrain.
- Increased Longevity: Alternating between two pairs extends the lifespan of each shoe, reducing wear and tear, which contributes to consistent performance and safety.
- Improved Comfort: A second pair can provide varying levels of comfort and fit, allowing climbers to manage foot fatigue better during long climbs or multi-pitch routes.
- Adaptability to Conditions: Different shoes can be better suited for varying climbing conditions, such as wet versus dry rock, ensuring optimal performance regardless of the environment.
Different Fit for Different Climbing Styles: Having a second pair allows climbers to choose a shoe that fits the specific demands of their climbing style, such as sport climbing, trad climbing, or bouldering. For instance, a stiffer shoe might be beneficial for edging on sport routes, while a softer shoe might excel in dynamic bouldering moves.
Specialized Features: Different climbing shoes can offer specialized features, like enhanced sensitivity or stiffness, which can improve grip and foot placement on varied terrain. A shoe designed for precision can help climbers tackle technical sections, while a more aggressive design can aid in steep overhangs.
Increased Longevity: Alternating between two pairs extends the lifespan of each shoe, reducing wear and tear, which contributes to consistent performance and safety. When shoes are allowed to rest and regain their shape, they maintain better performance over time.
Improved Comfort: A second pair can provide varying levels of comfort and fit, allowing climbers to manage foot fatigue better during long climbs or multi-pitch routes. Comfort can be critical in maintaining focus and performance during extended climbs, reducing the risk of injury.
Adaptability to Conditions: Different shoes can be better suited for varying climbing conditions, such as wet versus dry rock, ensuring optimal performance regardless of the environment. For example, shoes with a sticky rubber compound may perform better on slick surfaces, whereas others may excel on dry, rough rock.
Which Brands are Renowned for Quality Second Pair Climbing Shoes?
Some of the best brands renowned for quality second pair climbing shoes include:
- La Sportiva: La Sportiva is known for its innovative technology and high-performance climbing shoes that cater to a variety of climbing styles. Their models, such as the Theory and Miura, offer excellent support and precision, making them ideal for climbers looking for a versatile second pair that can handle both sport and trad climbing.
- Scarpa: Scarpa climbing shoes are designed with comfort and durability in mind, often featuring a slightly more relaxed fit that can be ideal for all-day wear. Options like the Drago and Vapor V provide a great balance of performance and comfort, making them suitable as a second pair for both training sessions and longer climbs.
- Five Ten: Five Ten is recognized for its aggressive rubber technology, providing exceptional grip on various surfaces. The Anasazi series and Hiangle are popular choices, offering a snug fit and excellent sensitivity, which can be beneficial for climbers looking for a shoe that excels in both sport climbing and bouldering.
- Black Diamond: Black Diamond combines functionality with style, offering shoes that are well-balanced for different climbing disciplines. Their Momentum and Zone models are perfect for beginners and intermediate climbers, providing comfort and support that make them a great choice for a second pair during longer climbing sessions.
- Evolv: Evolv climbing shoes are known for their affordability and performance, making them a great choice for climbers on a budget. The Shaman and Defy models are particularly popular, offering a comfortable fit and versatility for both sport climbing and bouldering, which is perfect for those looking for a reliable second pair.
What Features Set the Best Second Pair of Climbing Shoes Apart?
The best second pair of climbing shoes typically exhibit several key features that enhance performance and comfort for climbers transitioning to more advanced techniques.
- Fit and Comfort: A great second pair should provide a snug fit without causing discomfort, allowing for longer climbing sessions. This fit can help improve sensitivity on footholds and provide better control while climbing.
- Rubber Quality: The quality of the rubber used in climbing shoes significantly affects grip and durability. High-friction rubber offers better traction on various surfaces, while a durable rubber sole ensures longevity, making it suitable for different climbing environments.
- Downturn Shape: A moderate downturn shape is ideal for a second pair, as it allows for optimal power transfer to the toe while offering comfort for all-day wear. This shape helps climbers perform better on steep routes and overhangs while still being versatile enough for trad climbing.
- Closure System: The choice between Velcro and laces can influence ease of use and adjustability. Velcro systems provide convenience for quick on-and-off, while laces offer a customizable fit, making it easier to achieve the desired tension across the foot.
- Stiffness: A moderate level of stiffness is beneficial for a second pair, as it provides support for the foot on small footholds without sacrificing sensitivity. This balance allows climbers to feel the rock better while maintaining power during climbs.
- Breathability: Good breathability features, such as mesh panels or ventilation holes, help to keep feet cool and reduce moisture buildup. This is particularly important for comfort during long climbing sessions and can help prevent foot odor.
- Versatility: A versatile design allows the shoe to perform well in various climbing styles, from sport to trad to bouldering. This adaptability makes it a practical choice for climbers looking to progress and explore different climbing disciplines.
What are the Top Recommended Models for a Second Pair of Climbing Shoes?
The best second pair of climbing shoes are those that complement your primary pair, offering versatility and comfort for different climbing styles.
- La Sportiva Theory: This shoe is designed for sport climbing and bouldering, featuring a downturned shape that enhances precision on small footholds.
- Scarpa Drago: Known for its exceptional sensitivity and flexibility, the Drago is ideal for bouldering and steep sport routes, making it a great addition to your collection.
- Five Ten Anasazi VCS: This shoe combines comfort and performance, featuring a flat profile that is suitable for trad climbing and multi-pitch routes.
- Black Diamond Momentum: With a focus on comfort during long climbs, the Momentum offers a neutral fit and breathable materials, perfect for beginners or longer sessions.
- Sportiva Miura VS: This shoe balances performance and comfort, featuring a Velcro strap for easy adjustments, making it versatile for both sport climbing and trad.
The La Sportiva Theory is crafted for climbers who require a shoe that excels in technical situations. Its aggressive downturn allows for optimal power transfer and precision, making it perfect for challenging sport climbs and bouldering problems.
The Scarpa Drago stands out for its ability to provide a second-skin feel, enhancing the climber’s connection to the rock. Its soft rubber sole offers unparalleled grip on overhung routes, catering to those who prioritize sensitivity and performance in their climbing shoes.
The Five Ten Anasazi VCS is praised for its comfort and versatility, making it suitable for various climbing styles. Its flat design allows for great stability on longer climbs, while the breathable upper ensures comfort during extended wear.
Black Diamond Momentum shoes are particularly well-suited for beginners and those who enjoy longer climbs. With a soft and comfortable fit, they allow for easy wear during multi-pitch routes without sacrificing performance.
The Sportiva Miura VS combines a snug fit with a Velcro closure, making it easy to put on and take off between climbs. Its performance-oriented design makes it effective for both sport and traditional climbing, providing a balance between comfort and aggression.
How Can You Extend the Lifespan of Your Second Pair of Climbing Shoes?
To extend the lifespan of your second pair of climbing shoes, consider the following strategies:
-
Rotate Your Shoes: Alternate between your climbing shoes and your second pair. This allows each pair to dry out fully between uses, minimizing moisture-related damage.
-
Proper Cleaning: Remove dirt and debris after each climbing session. Use a soft brush or damp cloth to clean rubber, leather, and synthetic materials. Avoid submerging them in water, as this can weaken the shoe’s integrity.
-
Drying Techniques: After climbing, let your shoes air dry at room temperature. Avoid direct sunlight or heat sources, which can warp rubber and leather materials.
-
Use a Shoe Bag: Store your shoes in a breathable bag to protect them from dust and other environmental factors. A mesh bag allows for proper ventilation.
-
Toe and Heel Caps: Consider applying toe and heel caps, which provide extra protection to the most wear-prone areas of your shoes. These can significantly extend their lifespan.
-
Regular Inspections: Check for wear and tear, such as loose seams or degrading rubber. Addressing issues early can prevent further damage.
Implementing these practices will help preserve the performance and longevity of your second pair of climbing shoes.
Related Post: