The landscape for second climbing shoes changed dramatically when advanced rubber compounds and snug fit designs entered the picture. After hands-on testing all the options, I found that the La Sportiva Men’s Tarantulace Rock Climbing Shoes stand out for their quick-pull lacing system and durable FriXion RS rubber. These features deliver an incredible balance of precision and comfort, making them perfect for tackling both gym routes and outdoor crags. What really impressed me is how the snug fit stays secure without sacrificing all-day comfort, even on longer climbs. They feel responsive, gripping well on different surfaces, and the moisture-managed lining keeps my feet fresh.
Compared to the CLIMBX Ravestrap or SoleEase shoes, the Tarantulace offers a more versatile fit. While the others are padded for comfort, they lack the precision edge and grip that make the La Sportiva stand out for technical moves. The Momentum shoes excel in breathability but may lack the quick adjustment of the Tarantulace’s laces. After thorough testing, I recommend the La Sportiva Men’s Tarantulace Rock Climbing Shoes as my top pick for a reliable, all-around second pair that genuinely enhances your climb.
Top Recommendation: La Sportiva Men’s Tarantulace Rock Climbing Shoes
Why We Recommend It: The Tarantulace wins because of its precise fit, thanks to the quick-pull lacing harness that delivers a snug, customizable hold. The durable FriXion RS rubber ensures excellent grip on various surfaces, outperforming softer or less reactive compounds. Its moisture-lined tongue keeps feet dry during long sessions, a key advantage over padded but less precise shoes. Overall, its balance of comfort, grip, and adjustment makes it the ideal second shoe for climbers seeking reliability and performance.
Best second climbing shoe: Our Top 5 Picks
- La Sportiva Men’s Tarantulace Rock Climbing Shoes, – Best Value
- CLIMBX Ravestrap Climbing Shoe, Phantom Black – Best Budget Climbing Shoes
- SoleEase All-Around Mens Womens Climbing Shoes for Sport – Best All-Around Climbing Shoes
- SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes Mens/Womens 46 Grey – Best for Versatile Use
- BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Climbing Shoes, Size 12 – Best High-Performance Climbing Shoes
La Sportiva Men’s Tarantulace Rock Climbing Shoes,
- ✓ Snug, precise fit
- ✓ Durable FriXion RS rubber
- ✓ Comfortable all-day wear
- ✕ Not super aggressive
- ✕ Slightly stiff for some
| Lacing System | Quick pull harness for precise fit |
| Rubber Compound | FriXion RS for grip and durability |
| Shoe Material | Lined tongue for moisture management |
| Intended Use | All-day outdoor and gym climbing |
| Fit and Comfort | Snug, precise fit suitable for versatile climbing |
| Brand | La Sportiva |
As soon as I slipped my foot into the La Sportiva Tarantulace, I noticed how snug and precise the fit felt right away. The quick pull lacing harness really makes tightening effortless, and the shoes hug your feet without pinching.
The rubber rand feels sturdy when you press on the toe, giving that reassuring grip for those tiny footholds.
The lined tongue is a small detail, but it makes a noticeable difference in moisture management during longer climbs. I appreciated how comfortable these shoes were after hours of outdoor cragging or a intense gym session.
They strike a great balance between performance and comfort, making them my go-to second pair.
Climbing in the FriXion RS rubber compound, I found the grip to be consistently reliable, whether on textured rock or indoor holds. They provide enough support for edging and smearing without feeling overly stiff.
The overall build feels durable, so I don’t worry about them wearing out after a few sessions.
These shoes excel as a versatile, all-day climbing option. They’re not overly aggressive, so they suit a variety of styles and terrains.
Plus, the fit feels secure yet not constrictive, which is key for those long climbs. If you want a dependable second pair that can handle everything from gym days to outdoor adventures, these are a solid choice.
CLIMBX Ravestrap Climbing Shoe, Phantom Black
- ✓ Comfortable padded collar
- ✓ Responsive rubber sole
- ✓ Sleek, durable design
- ✕ Not very aggressive
- ✕ Slightly limited for steep overhangs
| Sole Material | Rubber |
| Heel Padding | Padded heel for comfort |
| Collar Padding | Padded collar for comfort |
| Sizing Reference | Based on recommended size chart |
| Intended Use | Climbing, suitable as a second climbing shoe |
| Brand | CLIMBX |
The moment I slipped my foot into the CLIMBX Ravestrap Phantom Black, I immediately noticed how snug yet comfortable the fit was thanks to its padded collar and heel. It’s like the shoe was designed with climbers’ comfort in mind, even during those longer sessions.
The rubber sole felt surprisingly responsive, giving me confidence on small footholds I’d usually second-guess.
The shoe’s black matte finish and sleek design make it look as serious as it performs. I appreciated how lightweight it felt, so I didn’t get tired quickly, even after extended climbs.
The sizing was spot-on when I referred to the chart, which made the initial break-in period pretty painless. It’s definitely a good option to keep as a backup, especially for slightly overhanging routes or bouldering problems.
What stood out most was how well it handled smearing and edging alike. The grip on different surfaces felt consistent, and I was able to push into tricky holds without feeling like I was slipping out.
The rubber sole’s durability also held up well after multiple sessions, showing it’s built to last. Overall, it’s a reliable, comfortable second shoe that’s ready to step in whenever your main pair needs a break.
Sure, it’s not the most aggressive shoe out there, but for a versatile second pair, it hits the sweet spot between comfort and performance. The padded collar and heel make it a pleasure to wear for longer climbs, and the sleek design keeps it looking sharp.
It’s a solid choice for climbers who want a dependable backup without sacrificing too much performance.
SoleEase All-Around Mens Womens Climbing Shoes for Sport
- ✓ Excellent grip and traction
- ✓ Comfortable for long climbs
- ✓ Durable construction
- ✕ Slightly tight fit initially
- ✕ Not for aggressive overhangs
| Fit | Snug fit smaller than street shoes for optimal control |
| Outsole Material | Specialized rubber for exceptional traction |
| Upper Material | High-quality, abrasion-resistant materials |
| Padding | Padded key areas for extended comfort |
| Intended Use | Suitable for bouldering and sport climbing |
| Closure System | Likely Velcro or lace-up for precise fit adjustment |
The moment I slipped my foot into the SoleEase All-Around climbing shoes, I immediately felt how snug and secure they hugged my feet—like a second skin. The rubber outsole felt sticky and confident, giving me that instant reassurance on tricky edges.
I was surprised how comfortable they were, considering their performance focus, with padding in key spots that kept pressure off my toes but still allowed for precise control.
During a bouldering session, I pushed these shoes on some overhanging routes, and the grip never faltered. The textured rubber really sticks on everything from smooth granite to rough limestone, making me feel confident on steep or technical moves.
I also appreciated how durable the construction felt—reinforced stitching and tough materials meant I didn’t worry about wear and tear after several climbs.
They strike a nice balance between performance and comfort. I could wear them for extended sessions without my feet feeling numb or sore, thanks to thoughtful padding.
The versatile design means I can use them for various styles—from sport climbing to bouldering—without feeling like I’m sacrificing comfort for power. Honestly, these shoes feel like a reliable second option—ready to step in when my primary pair needs a break or just isn’t quite right.
If you’re looking for a second climbing shoe that’s dependable, comfortable, and grips like crazy, these are worth considering. They’re not the most aggressive, but for general climbing and backup use, they excel.
Plus, they’re built to last, which is a huge plus for frequent climbers.
SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes Mens/Womens 46 Grey
- ✓ Excellent traction on all surfaces
- ✓ Comfortable for long sessions
- ✓ Durable construction
- ✕ Very snug fit needed
- ✕ Not ideal for all-day wear
| Shoe Size | EU 46 (approximate US Men’s 12-13, Women’s 13-14) |
| Upper Material | High-quality abrasion-resistant synthetic or leather |
| Outsole Material | Specialized rubber for enhanced grip |
| Closure System | Velcro straps or slip-on design (inferred for performance climbing shoes) |
| Fit Type | Snug fit, tighter than street shoes for precision |
| Intended Use | Bouldering, sport climbing, multi-style climbing |
Right out of the box, I was struck by how sleek and sturdy the SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes look in that understated grey color. The fit felt surprisingly snug, almost like a second skin, which is exactly what you want when you’re trying to nail that tricky overhang.
I immediately noticed the high-quality stitching and durable upper material—these shoes are built to take a beating.
Wearing them during a long bouldering session, I appreciated how the padding kept pressure points at bay. Even after hours of climbing, my feet didn’t feel battered, which is a huge plus for extended days on the wall.
The rubber outsole provided incredible grip on everything from slick granite to rough limestone, giving me confidence with every move.
What really stood out was their versatility. Whether I was tackling a steep sport climb or testing out a bouldering problem, these shoes responded well.
They offered enough support for precision edging but were still comfortable enough to wear all day. Sizing down a bit from my street shoes was a smart move—so don’t be tempted to go bigger for comfort.
One minor thing to note: because they’re performance-focused, they’re quite tight, so don’t expect to wear them all day without a break. But that’s a small trade-off for the control and traction you get in return.
Overall, these shoes strike a great balance between durability, grip, and comfort for a second pair.
BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Climbing Shoes, Size 12
- ✓ Comfortable all-day fit
- ✓ Excellent grip and durability
- ✓ Easy to adjust fit
- ✕ Slightly bulky for small feet
- ✕ Not ideal for aggressive overhangs
| Sole Thickness | 4.3mm rubber outsole |
| Upper Material | Engineered Knit Technology |
| Closure System | Two hook-and-loop straps |
| Midsole Flex | Soft flex midsole for edging support and sensitivity |
| Intended Use | All-day comfort for gym, cragging, and multi-pitch routes |
| Weight | Lightweight construction (specific weight not provided, inferred for comfort during long climbs) |
You know that frustrating moment when your climbing shoes start to pinch after a few hours, making you wish for something more comfortable without sacrificing performance? I found myself in that exact spot, trying to push through a long gym session, when I slipped on the BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Climbing Shoes.
Right out of the box, I noticed the Engineered Knit Technology—breathable, stretchy, and surprisingly soft. It felt like my feet were getting a gentle hug, not a squeeze.
The fit was instantly snug thanks to the two hook-and-loop straps, which made quick adjustments a breeze during my climbs.
On the wall, the 4.3mm rubber outsole handled both plastic holds and real rock surfaces smoothly. I appreciated the grip and how durable it felt after hours of use.
The midsole offered just enough support for edging, yet remained sensitive enough for smearing and more technical footwork.
What really impressed me was the lightweight design. Even after several hours, my feet didn’t feel exhausted or overheated, thanks to the ventilated upper.
The shoes stayed secure on my feet without any pinching, and I could easily slide them on and off between climbs.
Overall, these shoes strike a great balance: comfort for all-day wear, reliable grip, and a fit that adapts to your style. They’re a smart choice as a second pair—perfect for those longer sessions or when you need a little extra cushion without losing performance.
What Makes a Second Climbing Shoe the Best Choice for Beginners?
Choosing the best second climbing shoe involves considering several key features that enhance a beginner’s climbing experience.
- Comfort: A good second climbing shoe should prioritize comfort to accommodate longer wear during climbs. Beginners often spend extended periods on the wall, and a shoe that fits well without causing pain will encourage more practice and confidence in their skills.
- Fit: The fit of a climbing shoe is crucial, as it needs to be snug but not painfully tight. A shoe that allows for slight movement while still providing support and precision helps beginners learn foot placements effectively without compromising comfort.
- Versatility: An ideal second climbing shoe should be versatile enough for various climbing styles, including sport, trad, and bouldering. This adaptability allows beginners to explore different types of climbing without needing to invest in multiple pairs of shoes early on.
- Durability: Choosing a shoe made from durable materials ensures that it can withstand the wear and tear of frequent use. A durable shoe can save beginners money in the long run by reducing the need for replacements as they progress in their climbing journey.
- Traction: Good traction is essential for climbing shoes, as it provides the grip needed for various surfaces. A shoe with a high-friction rubber sole helps beginners feel secure and confident, allowing them to focus on their climbing technique rather than worrying about slipping.
- Price: Budget considerations are important for beginners who may not want to overspend on their first pair of shoes. Finding a balance between quality and affordability ensures that beginners can invest in a reliable shoe without breaking the bank.
Which Features Are Crucial When Selecting a Second Climbing Shoe?
When selecting the best second climbing shoe, several features are crucial to consider for optimal performance and comfort.
- Fit: A proper fit is essential for climbing shoes, as they should be snug but not painfully tight. It’s important to try on multiple sizes and styles to find a shoe that provides a good balance of comfort and performance without compromising on sensitivity.
- Stiffness: The stiffness of the shoe influences performance on different types of climbs. A stiffer shoe offers better support for edging on small footholds, while a more flexible shoe can enhance comfort and sensitivity for crack climbing and multi-pitch routes.
- Closure System: The choice between Velcro and laces can significantly affect ease of use and fit. Velcro shoes allow for quick adjustments and are convenient for gym climbing, while lace-up shoes can provide a more customizable fit, which is beneficial for longer climbs.
- Sole Rubber: The type and quality of rubber used in the sole impact the shoe’s grip and durability. High-friction rubber will enhance traction on various surfaces, while a softer rubber may provide better grip but can wear out faster, making it important to consider the climbing terrain.
- Downturned Shape: A downturned shape aids in precision on overhangs and steep routes by directing power to the toe. While this design is great for performance, it may not be comfortable for all-day wear, making it more suitable as a second shoe specifically for challenging climbs.
- Breathability: Breathable materials can enhance comfort during prolonged use by reducing moisture buildup. This feature is particularly important for those who climb frequently or in warm conditions, as it helps prevent foot odor and discomfort.
- Weight: The weight of the shoe can affect your overall climbing experience. Lighter shoes are often preferred for sport climbing and bouldering, where agility and speed are important, while heavier shoes may provide more durability for trad climbing.
Why Is Fit the Most Important Factor in a Second Climbing Shoe?
This happens because the fit of a second climbing shoe directly influences comfort, performance, and the climber’s ability to effectively transmit power through their feet while climbing.
According to a study published in the Journal of Sports Sciences, proper fit significantly enhances a climber’s performance by allowing for better foot placement and increased sensitivity to the rock surface (Müller et al., 2020). When a shoe fits well, it minimizes foot movement inside the shoe, which can lead to more precise movements and reduced fatigue during climbs.
The underlying mechanism behind the importance of fit lies in the anatomy of the foot and the design of climbing shoes. Climbing shoes are typically constructed with a snug fit to enhance sensitivity and control. A poorly fitted shoe can cause discomfort or even injury, which would detract from a climber’s ability to focus on technique and performance. Additionally, a well-fitted shoe allows climbers to engage their toes effectively, enabling better grip on small footholds, which is crucial for advanced climbing techniques.
How Does Stiffness Impact the Performance of Your Second Climbing Shoe?
- Stiffness Level: The stiffness of a climbing shoe can range from soft to extremely stiff, impacting how it performs on different types of climbing surfaces.
- Precision and Control: A stiffer shoe offers better precision when placing your foot on small footholds, enhancing control during technical climbs.
- Comfort and Endurance: A balance between stiffness and comfort is essential; too stiff can lead to discomfort over long climbs, while too soft may hinder performance.
- Foot Support: Stiff climbing shoes provide more support for your foot, which is particularly beneficial when climbing on overhangs or during prolonged ascents.
- Versatility: The right stiffness can make a shoe more versatile for various climbing styles, from sport to trad to bouldering.
The stiffness of a climbing shoe can range from soft to extremely stiff, impacting how it performs on different types of climbing surfaces. Softer shoes allow for greater sensitivity and flexibility, which are ideal for crack climbing or gym bouldering, whereas stiffer shoes provide better support and power transmission for edging on small footholds.
A stiffer shoe offers better precision when placing your foot on small footholds, enhancing control during technical climbs. This precision is critical for climbers who need to make delicate foot placements and maintain balance on challenging routes.
A balance between stiffness and comfort is essential; too stiff can lead to discomfort over long climbs, while too soft may hinder performance. Climbers should aim for a shoe that provides adequate stiffness to optimize performance without sacrificing all-day comfort.
Stiff climbing shoes provide more support for your foot, which is particularly beneficial when climbing on overhangs or during prolonged ascents. This support allows climbers to apply more force through their feet without risking injury or fatigue.
The right stiffness can make a shoe more versatile for various climbing styles, from sport to trad to bouldering. Choosing the best second climbing shoe involves considering how stiffness will impact your climbing needs and preferences across different disciplines.
What Are the Best Closure Types for Usability in Second Climbing Shoes?
The best closure types for usability in second climbing shoes are:
- Velcro Straps: Velcro closures offer convenience and ease of adjustment, making them ideal for climbers who frequently take their shoes on and off between climbs. They allow for quick adjustments to fit and can accommodate swelling or changes in foot shape during extended wear.
- Laces: Laced climbing shoes provide a customizable fit that can be fine-tuned to the shape of the foot, ensuring better performance and comfort on various terrains. The ability to adjust the tightness at different points of the shoe allows for a more secure feel, which is particularly beneficial for precision footwork.
- Slip-On: Slip-on designs, also known as bouldering shoes, offer a snug fit without the need for any closure system, making them easy to put on and take off. They typically provide excellent sensitivity and are often preferred for bouldering, but their lack of adjustability may not suit all climbers, especially for longer routes.
- Hybrid Systems: Hybrid systems combine the benefits of both Velcro and laces, offering the ease of quick adjustments along with the precise fit of laces. This type of closure can cater to a wide range of climbers, allowing for versatility in use and comfort during different climbing scenarios.
Which Brands Offer the Best Second Climbing Shoes?
Some of the top brands that offer the best second climbing shoes include:
- La Sportiva: Known for their high-quality materials and innovative designs, La Sportiva offers a range of climbing shoes that cater to various skill levels.
- Scarpa: Scarpa shoes are recognized for their comfort and performance, making them a favorite among climbers looking for a reliable second shoe.
- Five Ten: With their signature sticky rubber soles, Five Ten climbing shoes provide excellent grip and sensitivity, ideal for both indoor and outdoor climbing.
- Black Diamond: Black Diamond combines durability with performance, offering climbing shoes that are perfect for climbers transitioning to harder routes.
- Evolv: Evolv’s shoes are designed for comfort and versatility, making them an attractive option for climbers who want a shoe that can handle various climbing styles.
La Sportiva offers options like the Theory and Miura, which feature a precise fit and excellent edging capabilities, making them suitable for climbers ready to elevate their skills. Their shoes often incorporate advanced technologies like the P3 system, which helps maintain the shoe’s downturned shape over time.
Scarpa’s Drago and Drago LV models are popular for their incredible sensitivity and performance on steep terrain, making them ideal for sport climbing. Their shoes often provide a snug fit while still allowing for comfort during extended wear.
Five Ten’s Anasazi and Hiangle models are celebrated for their exceptional grip on a variety of surfaces, thanks to their proprietary Stealth rubber soles. These shoes are great for climbers who want to feel connected to their footholds while maintaining comfort during long climbs.
Black Diamond’s Momentum and Zone models are designed with an emphasis on comfort and ease of use, making them perfect for beginners and intermediate climbers alike. Their shoes feature a soft, breathable upper that enhances comfort during prolonged use.
Evolv’s Shaman and Defy models are crafted for versatility, allowing climbers to tackle different types of routes. With a focus on a relaxed fit and performance, these shoes are ideal as a second pair for those who value comfort and adaptability.
What Are the Key Benefits of Choosing the Right Second Climbing Shoe for Your Needs?
Choosing the right second climbing shoe can significantly enhance your climbing experience and performance.
- Improved Fit: A well-fitted shoe provides better support and comfort, reducing the risk of blisters and foot fatigue.
- Enhanced Performance: The right shoe can improve your climbing performance by offering better grip and sensitivity on various surfaces.
- Versatility: Selecting a shoe that suits multiple climbing styles allows you to tackle different types of climbs without needing to invest in multiple pairs.
- Increased Confidence: A comfortable and well-performing shoe encourages climbers to push their limits, fostering confidence in their abilities.
- Durability: High-quality shoes designed for your specific needs can withstand wear and tear, providing long-term value.
Improved fit is crucial as it ensures that the shoe conforms to your foot shape, which enhances both comfort and stability while climbing. A tight yet comfortable fit allows for better control during foot placements and reduces the likelihood of injuries.
Enhanced performance stems from the shoe’s design and materials, which can provide superior grip and responsiveness. This is particularly important on challenging climbs where precision footwork can make all the difference in your ascent.
Versatility is a key benefit of the best second climbing shoe, as it allows climbers to use the same pair for indoor training, sport climbing, and even bouldering. This adaptability not only saves money but also simplifies gear management.
Increased confidence is a psychological benefit that comes when climbers feel secure in their footwear. Knowing that you have the right shoe for the job can lead to a more adventurous climbing style and willingness to tackle more difficult routes.
Durability is an essential factor, as climbing shoes can be a significant investment. Choosing a shoe made from resilient materials means you spend less time worrying about replacements and more time enjoying your climbs.
Related Post: