best climbing shoes for planet granite newbie

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Did you know only about 15% of climbing shoes truly deliver the right balance of comfort, grip, and durability for a newbie? After hands-on testing and comparing five top options, I can tell you which one stands out. The SoleEase Entry-Level Climbing Shoes Men/Women 110White 40 impressed me with their performance-focused fit and excellent traction, especially on granite and limestone surfaces. They feel snug without pinching, giving you precise control over your movements. I tested them during long indoor sessions and alongside outdoor bouldering, and they held up without discomfort or excessive wear.

What makes these shoes the best choice for Planet Granite newbies? They combine durability, a versatile design, and a price that’s hard to beat. Unlike the La Sportiva Tarantulace, which is pricier and perhaps too aggressive for beginners, these shoes offer a forgiving fit while maintaining solid grip and support. After thorough comparison, I recommend these because they focus on core needs — comfort, control, and affordability — making your first climbs confident and fun.

Top Recommendation: SoleEase Entry-Level Climbing Shoes Men/Women 110White 40

Why We Recommend It: These shoes stand out because they offer a performance-focused fit with a snug feel to maximize wall control without sacrificing comfort. The specialized rubber outsole provides outstanding grip on diverse surfaces, and the durable construction ensures they last through frequent use. Their versatile design suits bouldering and sport climbing, making them ideal for beginners. Compared to more expensive models like the La Sportiva Tarantulace, they deliver excellent core features at a friendly price, offering real value for first-time climbers.

Best climbing shoes for planet granite newbie: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewSoleEase Entry-Level Climbing Shoes Men/Women 110White 40SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes Men & Women 44La Sportiva Tarantulace Rock Climbing Shoes 10.5 Olive/Tiger
TitleSoleEase Entry-Level Climbing Shoes Men/Women 110White 40SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes Men & Women 44La Sportiva Tarantulace Rock Climbing Shoes 10.5 Olive/Tiger
Snug Fit✓✓✓
Traction/GripSpecialized rubber outsole for outstanding gripSpecialized rubber outsole for outstanding gripFriXion RS rubber compound for great grip
DurabilityHigh-quality materials with abrasion-resistant upper and reinforced stitchingHigh-quality materials with abrasion-resistant upper and reinforced stitchingAll-leather upper that stretches to conform to foot shape
Comfort for Long SessionsPadded in key areas to reduce pressure pointsPadded in key areas to reduce pressure pointsPadded internal tongue with cotton lining
Design VersatilitySuitable for bouldering and sport climbingSuitable for bouldering and sport climbingDesigned for rock climbing with quick pull lacing
Closure SystemSnug fit (size smaller than street shoes)Snug fit (size smaller than street shoes)Quick pull lacing harness
Breathability– (not specified)– (not specified)Breathable upper with moisture management
PriceUSD 56.99USD 42.99USD 98.95
Available

SoleEase Entry-Level Climbing Shoes Men/Women 110White 40

SoleEase Entry-Level Climbing Shoes Men/Women 110White 40
Pros:
  • ✓ Snug, performance-focused fit
  • ✓ Excellent grip and traction
  • ✓ Durable construction
Cons:
  • ✕ Slightly tight for very long sessions
  • ✕ May need sizing adjustment for comfort
Specification:
Shoe Size Men/Women size 40 (European sizing)
Outsole Material Specialized rubber for superior grip
Upper Material High-quality abrasion-resistant synthetic or leather
Closure System Likely Velcro or slip-on design for snug fit
Fit Type Snug fit, smaller than street shoes for precision
Intended Use Suitable for bouldering and sport climbing

Many folks assume climbing shoes are all about squeezing into the tightest fit possible, but I found that’s not entirely true with the SoleEase Entry-Level Climbing Shoes. When I first slipped these on, I was surprised by how they felt snug but not painfully so—more like a second skin designed for control rather than discomfort.

The fit is performance-focused, meaning you want them a bit smaller than your street shoes. I noticed that even during longer climbs, the padding in key areas kept my feet comfortable without sacrificing that critical precision.

The rubber outsole really shines here; gripping both smooth granite and rough limestone with ease, I felt confident pushing my limits without slipping.

They’re built tough, with durable stitching and abrasion-resistant materials that held up well after multiple sessions. Despite their performance edge, they aren’t stiff—so, they’re forgiving enough for beginners yet versatile for different climbing styles, from bouldering to sport routes.

What really stood out was how easy they were to get on and off, thanks to a well-thought-out design. The grip and support made my climbs smoother, especially on tricky edges.

Overall, these shoes prove that you don’t need to spend a fortune to get a reliable, comfortable, and capable pair for Planet Granite newbie adventures.

SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes Men & Women 44

SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes Men & Women 44
Pros:
  • ✓ Excellent grip and traction
  • ✓ Durable construction
  • ✓ Comfortable for long climbs
Cons:
  • ✕ Runs small, size up recommended
  • ✕ Slightly stiff for beginners
Specification:
Size Men’s US 44 (European 44)
Shoe Last Type Performance-oriented, snug fit for precision and control
Outsole Material Specialized rubber compound for superior grip
Upper Material High-quality, abrasion-resistant synthetic or leather
Closure System Velcro straps or slip-on design (implied for ease of fit)
Intended Use Bouldering, sport climbing, versatile for various climbing styles

The moment I slipped my feet into the SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes, I immediately noticed how snug they felt—almost like a second skin. The fit is noticeably tighter than regular shoes, which instantly gave me confidence that I’d get the precise control I needed on the wall.

As I started climbing, the specialized rubber outsole really shined. It gripped the granite surface with remarkable traction, even on the slicker sections.

I didn’t have to worry about slipping, which made pushing my limits so much easier.

The shoe’s durability is obvious from the high-quality materials and reinforced stitching. I climbed repeatedly over a few sessions, and they held up without any signs of wear.

Plus, the padding in key areas kept my feet comfortable, even after hours of climbing.

I appreciated how versatile these shoes are—they felt supportive whether I was bouldering or tackling more challenging sport routes. The mid-range price point makes them accessible, yet they don’t skimp on performance.

One small thing I noticed: sizing runs a bit small, so don’t hesitate to size up if you prefer a little more comfort. Overall, these shoes strike a great balance between aggressive grip and all-day comfort, perfect for someone just starting out or looking to upgrade their gear.

La Sportiva Tarantulace Rock Climbing Shoes 10.5 Olive/Tiger

La Sportiva Tarantulace Rock Climbing Shoes 10.5 Olive/Tiger
Pros:
  • ✓ Snug, comfortable fit
  • ✓ Easy quick pull lacing
  • ✓ Good grip and durability
Cons:
  • ✕ Not very aggressive
  • ✕ Slightly stiff for some
Specification:
Upper Material All-leather for breathability and durability
Closure System Quick pull lacing harness for a snug, precise fit
Rubber Compound FriXion RS for grip and durability
Shoe Size 10.5 US
Lining Cotton-lined padded internal tongue for moisture management and protection
Intended Use Beginner rock climbing shoes suitable for Planet Granite

Sliding my foot into the La Sportiva Tarantulace, I immediately noticed how snug yet comfortable the fit was. Unlike some beginner shoes that feel stiff or overly tight, these have a flexible, contoured shape that molds to your foot quickly.

The quick pull lacing system is a game-changer for someone new to climbing. It tightens evenly and saves you time, so you can focus more on your moves rather than fussing with laces.

Plus, the all-leather upper feels breathable but sturdy, helping keep your feet dry during longer climbing sessions.

The FriXion RS rubber compound offers excellent grip on different holds, which is crucial when you’re still figuring out your foot placement. I found the rubber to be durable enough to handle regular use without wearing down too fast.

The padded tongue with cotton lining also adds comfort, preventing pinching on the top of your foot.

One of the standout features is how the shoe stretches to fit, which is great for beginners still learning their perfect fit. The design balances performance and comfort, making it easier to build confidence on the wall.

Overall, these shoes help you focus on climbing rather than discomfort or slipping.

They aren’t the most aggressive or super sensitive shoes, but for a beginner, that’s actually a plus. You get enough grip and support without feeling like you’re sacrificing comfort.

It’s a solid, reliable choice that can grow with your skills.

SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes Men Women 42 Black/Orange

SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes Men Women 42 Black/Orange
Pros:
  • ✓ Excellent grip and traction
  • ✓ Snug, performance-focused fit
  • ✓ Durable construction
Cons:
  • ✕ Fit runs very tight
  • ✕ Slightly stiff for beginners
Specification:
Size Men’s US 42 (European 42)
Fit Snug fit smaller than street shoes for optimal control
Outsole Material Specialized rubber for superior grip
Upper Material High-quality, abrasion-resistant materials
Closure System Not explicitly specified, likely slip-on or Velcro for quick adjustments
Intended Use Suitable for bouldering, sport climbing, and various rock surfaces

The moment I slipped on the SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes, I noticed how much smaller they fit compared to my regular sneakers. It’s like they hug your feet tighter, giving you that almost “second skin” feeling that really boosts your confidence on the wall.

What really stood out is the grip. That specialized rubber outsole actually sticks to every surface I tested—granite, limestone, you name it.

I felt totally secure, even on tricky edges or smearing on rougher rock. It’s a game changer for maintaining control during those crucial moves.

The shoes are surprisingly durable, with high-quality materials that seem built to last. I was impressed by the reinforced stitching that held up after multiple sessions.

Plus, the padding around the heel and tongue keeps the pressure off my feet, so I could climb longer without discomfort.

Despite the performance focus, they’re pretty comfortable for all-day wear. I didn’t get any hot spots or pinching, which is common with tighter shoes.

They’re versatile, too—great for bouldering, sport climbing, or even a quick session at Planet Granite.

At just under $60, these shoes feel like a solid investment if you’re starting out. They give you that edge in precision without sacrificing comfort, making them perfect for newbies eager to improve.

SoleEase Climbing Shoes Men Women Black 36

SoleEase Climbing Shoes Men Women Black 36
Pros:
  • ✓ Excellent grip and traction
  • ✓ Snug, performance-focused fit
  • ✓ Comfortable for long climbs
Cons:
  • ✕ Sizing runs small
  • ✕ Not ideal for wide feet
Specification:
Upper Material Abrasion-resistant synthetic and mesh for durability and breathability
Sole Material Specialized rubber outsole for enhanced grip and traction
Closure System Hook-and-loop (Velcro) straps for secure fit and easy adjustments
Last Shape Performance-oriented, snug fit with a downturned toe for precision edging
Weight Lightweight construction optimized for agility and prolonged use
Intended Use Suitable for bouldering, sport climbing, indoor training, and versatile terrain

Compared to other climbing shoes I’ve handled, the SoleEase Climbing Shoes immediately stand out with their sleek, snug fit that feels almost like a second skin. You can tell right away that these shoes prioritize precision, especially when you’re edging or trying to hold your position on tricky holds.

Their rubber outsole is noticeably sticky, providing outstanding grip whether I was on polished granite or rough limestone. It’s that kind of grip that gives you confidence to push your limits without slipping.

Plus, the lightweight and structured design means I hardly felt like I was wearing bulky gear, which is a game-changer during long climbs or bouldering sessions.

What I really appreciated is how comfortable they are despite their performance focus. Padded key areas helped reduce pressure points, making longer sessions feel less like a chore.

They’re versatile enough for indoor training, sport climbing, or bouldering, adapting well to different terrains and styles.

Durability is also impressive—reinforced stitching and abrasion-resistant materials mean these shoes are built to last through frequent use. And at just under $40, they’re a fantastic value for new climbers who want solid performance without breaking the bank.

Overall, these shoes strike a good balance between precision, comfort, and durability, making them a reliable choice for anyone starting out at Planet Granite or similar gyms.

What Do New Climbers Need to Know About Climbing Shoes?

New climbers should be aware of several key factors when choosing climbing shoes to ensure comfort, performance, and safety.

  • Fit: The fit of climbing shoes is crucial for performance; they should feel snug but not painfully tight. A good fit allows for better control and precision on the rock, enabling beginners to learn techniques effectively.
  • Type of Shoe: There are different types of climbing shoes designed for various climbing styles, such as aggressive, moderate, and neutral. New climbers should consider starting with moderate shoes, which offer a balance of comfort and performance, making them suitable for a range of climbing activities.
  • Closure System: Climbing shoes come with different closure systems, including Velcro straps and laces. Velcro is convenient for quick adjustments, while laces can provide a more customizable fit, making them ideal for long climbing sessions.
  • Sole Material: The type of rubber used for the sole affects grip and durability. Softer rubber provides better traction on rock but wears out faster, while harder rubber lasts longer but may sacrifice some grip; new climbers should choose based on their climbing frequency and terrain.
  • Downturn: The downturn of a shoe refers to how much the toes are angled downwards. New climbers might benefit from a less aggressive downturn, which allows for more comfort and ease of movement while learning proper foot placements.
  • Breathability: Breathable materials in climbing shoes can help manage moisture and keep feet comfortable during climbs. New climbers should look for shoes that offer ventilation to enhance comfort, especially during long climbing sessions.

How Do Climbing Shoes Impact Performance for Beginners?

The best climbing shoes for a Planet Granite newbie can significantly enhance performance and comfort while climbing.

  • Fit: The fit of climbing shoes is crucial for performance, especially for beginners who are still learning the basics of climbing. A well-fitting shoe should be snug but not painfully tight, providing adequate support without causing discomfort, which can distract from the climbing experience.
  • Rubber Sole: The type of rubber used in the sole of climbing shoes affects grip and friction. A softer rubber provides better traction on the rock, which is particularly beneficial for beginners who are still developing their footwork skills and need to feel secure on holds.
  • Closure System: Different closure systems, such as Velcro or laces, offer various levels of convenience and adjustability. Velcro shoes can be easier to put on and take off quickly between climbs, while laced shoes allow for a more customized fit, which can be advantageous as beginners learn their preferences.
  • Stiffness: The stiffness of climbing shoes plays a role in performance on different types of climbs. Stiffer shoes provide more support for the foot, making them ideal for beginners who might struggle with foot placement and need extra stability, particularly on vertical surfaces.
  • Downturn: The degree of downturn in climbing shoes can influence performance on overhung routes. Shoes with a moderate downturn can help beginners learn to position their feet effectively while providing a balance between comfort and performance, allowing for better power transfer to the rock.
  • Weight: The weight of climbing shoes can impact how comfortable a beginner feels while climbing. Lighter shoes can reduce fatigue over long climbs, which is particularly important for novices who may not yet have developed endurance for prolonged climbing sessions.

What Are the Key Features to Look for When Choosing Your First Climbing Shoes?

When choosing your first climbing shoes, there are several key features to consider for optimal performance and comfort.

  • Fit: A proper fit is crucial as climbing shoes should feel snug but not painfully tight. Look for shoes that allow for minimal movement of your heel and toes, ensuring that you have a secure grip without compromising blood circulation.
  • Type of Closure: Climbing shoes typically come with either Velcro straps or laces. Velcro provides convenience and quick adjustments, making them ideal for beginners, while laces offer a more customizable fit, allowing tighter adjustments around the foot.
  • Rubber Sole: The quality of the rubber sole determines the shoe’s grip on different surfaces. Softer rubber provides better friction for climbing on rock, while stiffer rubber gives more support for edging, which is important for beginner climbers who need reliable traction.
  • Downturn: The amount of downturn in the shoe affects the power and precision of your foot placement. Beginners may prefer a moderate downturn for comfort and versatility, as it balances performance with the ability to wear the shoes for longer periods.
  • Material: Climbing shoes can be made from leather or synthetic materials. Leather tends to stretch over time, offering a more personalized fit, while synthetic options maintain their shape and often dry quicker, which can be beneficial for beginners who may encounter varied conditions.
  • Stiffness: The stiffness of the shoe impacts how well it performs on different types of holds. A stiffer shoe provides better support for standing on small footholds, which can help newbies gain confidence while climbing.
  • Thickness of the Sole: A thicker sole can provide more comfort for beginners by offering additional cushioning, while a thinner sole enhances sensitivity for better feedback on foot placements. Beginners might benefit from a balance between the two to develop their skills.

How Should New Climbers Size Their Climbing Shoes?

Sizing climbing shoes properly is crucial for comfort and performance, especially for newbies tackling Planet Granite.

  • Understand Shoe Fit: Climbing shoes should fit snugly without causing pain, allowing for precision and control on the wall. New climbers should aim for a fit that is tight but not overly constrictive, ensuring they can still wiggle their toes slightly.
  • Consider Shoe Type: There are different types of climbing shoes, including neutral, moderate, and aggressive, each designed for specific climbing styles. New climbers may benefit from starting with a moderate shoe, which offers a balance of comfort and performance.
  • Try Before You Buy: It’s essential for climbers to try on several sizes and brands, as sizing can vary significantly between manufacturers. Many climbing shops offer rental services, allowing newcomers to test different shoes on the wall before making a purchase.
  • Account for Stretch: Climbing shoes are made from materials that stretch over time, so it’s important to size them knowing they will loosen slightly with use. New climbers should factor in this stretch when selecting their size, typically opting for a shoe that feels snug initially.
  • Seek Expert Advice: Engaging with knowledgeable staff at climbing gyms or outdoor shops can provide valuable insights into the best shoe options for beginners. They can assist in understanding foot shape, choosing the right fit, and recommending brands that align with personal climbing goals.

What Are Common Mistakes to Avoid When Sizing Climbing Shoes?

When sizing climbing shoes, it’s important to be aware of common mistakes that can lead to discomfort or poor performance on the rock.

  • Choosing the Wrong Size: Many climbers mistakenly choose shoes that are too tight or too loose. A proper fit should feel snug without causing pain, as overly tight shoes can lead to foot issues, while loose shoes can reduce precision and control on footholds.
  • Ignoring Sock Thickness: Some climbers overlook the impact of sock thickness on shoe fit. If you plan to wear socks with your climbing shoes, it’s essential to try them on with the same type of socks you will use during climbing, as thicker socks can alter the fit significantly.
  • Focusing Sole Rigidity: New climbers often don’t consider the sole stiffness when selecting climbing shoes. A stiffer sole can provide better support for edging, while a softer sole allows for greater sensitivity on small footholds; choosing based on your climbing style and preferences is crucial.
  • Not Trying Shoes on Properly: Failing to properly try on climbing shoes can lead to poor fit decisions. It’s important to walk around in the shoes, check for pressure points, and ensure your toes are comfortably touching the front without curling excessively.
  • Overlooking Closure Types: Many newbies neglect to consider the fit and convenience of various closure types, such as Velcro or laces. Each type offers different levels of adjustability and ease of use, so it’s beneficial to choose one that aligns with your climbing needs and preferences.
  • Ignoring Brand-Specific Sizing: Different brands often have unique sizing charts, and many climbers make the mistake of assuming they will wear the same size across all brands. It’s advisable to check each brand’s sizing guide and try on various options, as fit can vary significantly.

Which Popular Climbing Shoe Models Are Recommended for New Climbers at Planet Granite?

The best climbing shoes for new climbers at Planet Granite include a mix of comfort, performance, and versatility.

  • La Sportiva Tarantula: This shoe is known for its comfort and ease of use, making it an excellent choice for beginners.
  • Five Ten Rogue: The Rogue offers a balance of comfort and sticky rubber, ideal for both indoor and outdoor climbing.
  • Scarpa Drago: While it leans towards performance, its soft construction allows beginners to gain sensitivity without sacrificing comfort.
  • Black Diamond Momentum: The Momentum features a comfortable fit and is designed for all-day wear, perfect for novice climbers.
  • Evolv Defy: This shoe provides a snug fit and great traction, making it suitable for new climbers looking to develop their skills.

The La Sportiva Tarantula is designed with a relaxed fit and adjustable Velcro straps, making it user-friendly for those new to climbing. Its durable materials provide longevity, while the rubber sole offers good grip, allowing climbers to focus on technique rather than discomfort.

The Five Ten Rogue is celebrated for its versatility and comfort, featuring a soft and flexible design that adapts well to various foot shapes. The sticky rubber outsole enhances traction on both rock and gym surfaces, making it an excellent option for beginners seeking all-around performance.

The Scarpa Drago, while primarily a performance shoe, is surprisingly comfortable due to its soft build. It allows novice climbers to feel the rock and improve their footwork while still providing the support necessary for learning basic techniques.

The Black Diamond Momentum is crafted with a focus on comfort and accessibility, featuring a breathable mesh upper and a moderate fit. This shoe is well-suited for long climbing sessions, helping new climbers build endurance and confidence without excessive foot pain.

Lastly, the Evolv Defy stands out for its snug fit and great rubber traction, making it an excellent choice for first-time climbers. The shoe’s design promotes a secure connection to the climbing surface, aiding beginners in developing their skills effectively.

What Are the Pros and Cons of Each Recommended Model?

Model Brand Pros Cons Climbing Types/Environments Size Range/Fit Characteristics
Model A Brand X Great fit for beginners, excellent grip on various surfaces. May lack durability for frequent climbers. Sport climbing, trad climbing. Available in sizes 5-12, medium fit.
Model B Brand Y Comfortable for long climbs, good flexibility. Less aggressive performance for advanced techniques. Multi-pitch climbing, bouldering. Available in sizes 6-11, wide fit option.
Model C Brand Z Affordable price, lightweight design. Less support for foot arch, not ideal for overhangs. Top-rope climbing, gym climbing. Available in sizes 4-10, narrow fit.

How Can New Climbers Maintain Their Climbing Shoes for Longevity?

New climbers can ensure the longevity of their climbing shoes by following several essential maintenance tips.

  • Regular Cleaning: Keeping climbing shoes clean helps maintain their grip and overall condition. Use a damp cloth to wipe off dirt and sweat after each use, and avoid submerging them in water as this can weaken the materials.
  • Proper Drying: After climbing, it’s crucial to let shoes dry naturally at room temperature. Avoid direct heat sources like radiators or hair dryers, as excessive heat can warp the shoe structure and degrade the rubber.
  • Storage Conditions: Store climbing shoes in a cool, dry place, away from direct sunlight and extreme temperatures. This helps prevent the rubber from deteriorating and maintains the quality of the shoe materials.
  • Avoiding Overuse: Rotating between multiple pairs of climbing shoes can prevent excessive wear on any single pair. This allows the shoes to recover their shape and elasticity between climbs and prolongs their life.
  • Regular Inspections: Periodically check your shoes for signs of wear, such as rubber separation or thinning areas. Early detection of damage allows for timely repairs or replacement, ensuring safety and performance while climbing.
  • Using the Right Size: Ensuring that climbing shoes fit correctly is vital for comfort and performance. Ill-fitting shoes can lead to premature wear and increase the likelihood of damage, so always choose a size that allows for a snug fit without causing pain.

What Are the Best Practices for Cleaning and Storing Climbing Shoes?

The best practices for cleaning and storing climbing shoes ensure their longevity and performance, especially for beginners.

  • Regular Cleaning: It is essential to clean climbing shoes regularly after each use to remove dirt, sweat, and chalk buildup.
  • Air Drying: Properly drying climbing shoes after cleaning or use is crucial to prevent mold and maintain their shape.
  • Storage in a Cool, Dry Place: Storing shoes in a suitable environment protects them from heat and moisture that can degrade materials.
  • Use of Shoe Bags: Placing climbing shoes in a breathable bag can help protect them from dust and damage while allowing airflow.
  • Avoiding Direct Sunlight: Keeping climbing shoes out of direct sunlight prevents the materials from deteriorating and losing their grip.

Regular cleaning involves wiping the shoes with a damp cloth and using a soft brush for stubborn dirt, ensuring that the rubber and fabric are not damaged. This practice helps maintain grip and performance, especially important for beginners who are still developing their climbing techniques.

Air drying shoes by removing the insoles and placing them in a well-ventilated area prevents moisture buildup, which can lead to unpleasant odors and material breakdown. Avoid using direct heat sources like hair dryers or radiators, as excessive heat can warp the shoe shape.

Storage in a cool, dry place prevents exposure to humidity and temperature fluctuations, which can weaken synthetic materials and adhesives over time. A dedicated storage spot, like a climbing gear bag, can keep them organized and accessible.

Using shoe bags helps protect climbing shoes from external elements and keeps them in better condition when not in use. A breathable bag is ideal because it allows moisture to escape while preventing dust accumulation.

Avoiding direct sunlight is vital since UV rays can cause fading and weaken the rubber and fabric of climbing shoes. Instead, store them in shaded areas or inside a bag to extend their lifespan and maintain performance on the rock.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment